@misc{cogprints2385, volume = {6}, month = {October}, title = {Impact of Generalist Physician Initiatives on Residency Selection }, author = {Michael H. Malloy MD and Christine A. Stroup-Benham PhD}, year = {2001}, journal = {Medical Education Online}, keywords = {Generalist physician initiative, primary care, residency selection, career choice, medical education, health professions education}, url = {http://cogprints.org/2385/}, abstract = {Objective:To compare the residency selection choices of students who experienced courses resulting from generalist physician initiatives to choices made by students prior to the implementation of those courses and to describe the characteristics of students selecting primary care residencies. Background:In the fall of 1994 a first year Community Continuity Experience course was initiated and in the summer of 1995 a third year Multidisciplinary Ambulatory Clerkship was begun at the University of Texas Medical Branch in Galveston. These courses were inserted into the curriculum to enhance and promote primary care education. Design/Methods:We examined the residency selections of cohorts of graduating medical students before (1992-1996) and after (1997-1999) the implementation of the primary care courses. Survey information on career preferences at matriculation and in the fourth year of medical school were available for students graduating after the programs began. We compared the career preferences and characteristics of those students who selected a primary care residency to those who did not. Results:Prior to the implementation of the programs, 45\%(425/950) of students graduating selected primary care residencies compared to 45\% (210/465) of students participating in the programs (p=0.88). At matriculation, 45\% of students had listed a primary care discipline as their first career choice. Among the students who had indicated this degree of primary care interest 61\% ended up matching in a primary care discipline. At year 4, 31\% of students indicated a primary care discipline as their first career choice and 92\% of these students matched to a primary care residency. By univariate analysis, minority students (53\%) were more likely to select a primary care residency than non-minority students (40\%); students in the two lowest grade point average quartiles (55\% and 50\%) selected primary care residencies compared to 37\% and 38\% of students in the top 2 quartiles; and students who stated that income potential had little or no impact on their choice were more likely to select a primary care residency (48\%) than those who said income potential was important (37\%). Conclusions:We observed no significant trend towards higher proportions of graduating students selecting primary care discipline residencies as a result of implementing courses that emphasized primary care. Those students expressing an interest in a primary care discipline at their entrance into medical school were more likely to select a primary care residency. A more significant impact on graduating students interested in primary care may be made through the medical student selection process than by altering the curriculum. } }