P-model Alternative to the T-model.

Roberts, Mark D. (1995) P-model Alternative to the T-model. (Unpublished)


There is a more recent version of this eprint available. Click here to view it.

Full text available as:



Standard linguistic analysis of syntax uses the T-model. This model requires the ordering: D-structure $>$ S-structure $>$ LF, where D-structure is the deep structure, S-structure is the surface structure, and LF is logical form. Between each of these representations there is movement which alters the order of the constituent words; movement is achieved using the principles and parameters of syntactic theory. Psychological analysis of sentence production is usually either serial or connectionist. Psychological serial models do not accommodate the T-model immediately so that here a new model called the P-model is introduced. The P-model is different from previous linguistic and psychological models. Here it is argued that the LF representation should be replaced by a variant of Frege's three qualities (sense, reference, and force), called the Frege representation or F-representation. In the F-representation the order of elements is not necessarily the same as that in LF and it is suggested that the correct ordering is: F-representation $>$ D-structure $>$ S-structure. This ordering appears to lead to a more natural view of sentence production and processing. Within this framework movement originates as the outcome of emphasis applied to the sentence. The requirement that the F-representation precedes the D-structure needs a picture of the particular principles and parameters which pertain to movement of words between representations. In general this would imply that there is a preferred or optimal ordering of the symbolic string in the F-representation. The standard ordering is retained because the general way of producing such an optimal ordering is unclear. In this case it is possible to produce an analysis of movement between LF and D-structure similar to the usual analysis of movement between S-structure and LF. It is suggested that a maximal amount of information about a language's grammar and lexicon is stored, because of the necessity of analyzing corrupted data.

Item Type:Other
Keywords:T-model, movement, Frege Representation.
Subjects:Psychology > Cognitive Psychology
Linguistics > Syntax
ID Code:933
Deposited By:Roberts, Dr. Mark D.
Deposited On:14 Aug 2000
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:54

Available Versions of this Item

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.


Akman, Varol \& Surav, Mehmet$~~~\S5.1$\\

Steps Towards Formalizing Context.\\


{\it AI Magazine} {\bf 17}(1998)55-72.



Deriving the Predicate-Argument Structure \\

for a Free Word Order Language.\\

{\tt} 20 Aug.1998


Brants, Thorsten$~~~\S1.1$\\

Cascaded Markov Models.\\

In: Comutational Natural Language Learning (CoNLL-99).

A Workshop at the 9th Conference of the European Chapter of the

Assoc. for Computational Linguistics (EACL-99), Bergen, Norway, June 1999.\\



Brody, Michael$~~~\S1.3$\\

Projection \& Phrase Structure.\\

{\it Ling.Inq.} {\bf 29}(1998)367-398.


%Cairns,P., Shillcock,R., Chater,N. \& Levy, J.P.$~~~\S\P$\\

%Bottom-up Connectionist Moddeling of Speech.\\

%p.289, in Connectionist models of Meemory \& Language.\\

%eds.J.P.Levy, D.Bairaktaris, J.A. Bullinaria \& P.Cairns\\

%UCL Press (1995).


%Carrier, Jill \& Randall, Janet H.$~~~\S\P$\\

%The Argument Structure and Syntatic Structure of Resultativwes.

%{\it Ling.Inq.}{\bf 23}(1992)173-234.



Knowledge of Language:

Its Nature, Origin, and Use.\\

Praeger(1986), New York.


Clarke,H.H. \& Clarke,E.V.$~~~\S5.2$\\

The Psychology of Language,\\

Harcourt Brace Jonanovich, (1977) New York.



Chomsky's Universal Grammar: An Introduction.\\

Basil Blackwell, (1988)Oxford.


Culicover, Peter W.$~~~\S3.1$\\

The Minimalist Impulse.\\

{\it Syntax \& Semantics} {\bf 29}(1998)47-77.


Downing,P. and Noonan, M.(eds)$~~~\S3.2$\\

Word Order in Discourse,

Typological Studies in Language (TSL)\\

John Benjamin Publishing Company, (1995)Amsterdam.



FREGE Philosophy of Language,\\

Duckworth London,(1973)

Second Edition (1981)p.83.


Ferro, Lisa; Vilain, Marc \& Yeh, Alexander$~~~\S1.2,5.1$\\

Learning Transformation Rules to Find Grammatical Relations.\\

In: Comutational Natural Language Learning (CoNLL-99)pp 43-55.\\

A Workshop at the 9th Conference of the European Chapter of the \\

Assoc. for Computational Linguistics (EACL-99),\\

Bergen, Norway, June 1999.\\



Frazier, Lyn$~~~\S5.4$\\

Sentence Processing:

A Tutorial Reviw.\\

{\it Attention \& Performance} {\bf XII},

The Psychology of Reading.\\

edited Max Coltheart(1987)559-586.



Psycholinguistics, (1990)\\Cambridge University Press.



Levels of Processing in Sentence Production,\\

Ch.{\bf 8} in B.Butterworth (ed.), Language Production,Vol.{\bf 1},\\

Academic Press(1980), London.


Gerdemann Dale \& van Noord Gertjan$~~~\S5.1$\\

Transducers from Rewrite Rules with Backreferences.\\



Gibson, Edward$~~~\S3.1$\\

Linguistic Complexity:

Locality of Syntactic Dependencies.\\

{\it Cognition} {\bf 68}(1998)1-76.


Graesser, Author C.; Millis Keith K. \& Zwaan Rolf A.$~~~\S5.1$\\

Discourse Comprehesion.\\

{\it Annu.Rev.Psychol.}{\bf 48}(1997)163-89.


Gleitman, Lila \& Bloom, Paul$~~~\S1.2$\\

Language Acquisition.(1998)\\




Introduction to Government and Binding Theory.\\

Second Edition, Basil Blackwell, (1994) Oxford.


Hall, Christopher J.$~~~\S1.1,5.1$\\

Formal Linguistic \& Mental Representations:

Psycholinguistic Contributions to the Indentification and

Explanation of Morphological \& Syntatic Competence.\\

{\it Lang,\& Cog.Processes} {\bf 10}(1995)169-187.



Logical Form: from GB to minimalism.\\

Blackwell, (1995) Massachusetts.



The Theory of Parameters \& Syntatic Development.(1985)\\

p.1 in Parameter Setting, eds. T.Roeper \& E.Williams.\\

D.Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht.



Electrophysiology of Mental Activities.\\

{\it Am.J.Psy.}, {\bf 44}(1932)677-94,especially page 692.


Johnson,M. \& Klein,E.$~~~\S4.1$\\

Discourse, Anaphora and Pharsing,\\

{\it CSLI Report}(1986)86-63.


Johnson,M. \& Klein,E.$~~~\S4.1$\\

A Declarative Formulation of Discourse Representation Theory.\\

{\it J.Sym.Logic} {\bf 51}(1986)846.


Josephson Brain D. \& Blair David G.$~~~\S1.2$\\

A Holistic Approach to Language.\\



%Kess, J.F.$\S\P$\\

%Pyscholinguistics, Psychology, Linguistics,\\

%and the Study of Natural Language.\\

%John Benjamins Publishing company, Amsterdam.\\

%(p.117(sentence processing - neagtives.)






Lee, Mark \& Wilks, Yorick$~~~\S3.1$\\

An Ascription-based Approach to Speech Acts.\\

In: Proceeedings of Coling -96, Copenhagen.\\



MacDonald,Maryellen C.; Pearlmutter, Neal J.\\

\& Seidedberg, Mark S.$~~~\S5.1$\\

Lexical Nature of Syntatic Ambiguity Resolution.\\

{\it Psy.Rev.}{\bf 101}(1994)676-703.


MacWinney, Brian$~~~\S1.2$\\

Models of the Emergence of Language.\\

{\it Annu.Rev.Psychol.}{\bf 49}(1998)199-227.


Marslen-Wilson,William D.$~~~\S4.4$\\

Functional Parallelism in Spoken Word-recogition.\\

{\it Coginition} {\bf 25}(1987)71-102.


%Marslen-Wilson,William D.; Tyler, Lorraine Komisarjevsky;\\

%Waksler, Rachelle \& Older, Lianne$~~~\S\P$\\



Logical Form: its structure and derivation.\\

MIT Press (1985),Massachusetts.\\

\& Logical Form in Linguistics.\\



McCloskey, James$~~~\S1.1$\\

in Linguistics (1988): the Cambridge Survey.\\

Cambridge University Press.


McGurk,H. and McDonald,J.$~~~\S4.2$\\

Hearing Lips and Seeing Voices.\\

{\it Nature} {\bf 264}(1976)746-8.


McDonald, Janet L.$~~~\S1.2$\\

Language Acquisition:

The Acquisition of Linguistic Structure\\

in Normal and Special Populations.\\

{\it Ann.Rev.Psychol.}{\bf 48}(1997)215-241.


McKoon,Gail \& Ratcliff,Rober$~~~\S5.1$\\

Memory-based Language Processing:\\

Psycholinguinguistic Research in the 1990's.\\

{\it Annu.Rev.Psychol.}{\bf 49}(1998)25-42.



So You Think That Gestures are Non Verbal?\\

{\it Psy.Rev.} {\bf 92}(1985)350-371.


McRea, Ken \& Spivey-Knowlton, Michael J.$~~~\S5.4$\\

Modeling the Influence of Thematic Fit (and other Constraints)\\

in On-line Sentence Comprehension.\\

{\it J.Mem.\&Lang.}{\bf 38}(1998)283-312.



Formal Logic.\\

Second Edition (1962),

Claredon Press, Oxford.


Rischel, J{\o}rgen$~~~\S1.1$\\

Formal Linguistics \& Real Speech.\\

{\it Speech Communication} {\bf 11}(1992)379-392.


Roberts,Mark D.$~~~\S1.2$\\

Radical interpretation Described using Terms\\ from Biological Evolution.\\



Roberts,Mark D.$~~~\S3.1$\\

Ultrametric Distance in Syntax.\\



%Rogers, James$~~~\S\P$\\

%A Model-Theoretic Framework for Theories of Syntax.\\

%In: Proceedings of the 34th Annual Meeting of the ACL,\\

%Santa Cruz, USA (1996)\\

%{\tt cmp-lg/9604023}



Sentence Production: Developments in Research and Theory.\\

Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, (1977)New Jersey.


Seidenberg,M.S. and McClelland,J.L.$~~~\S4.2$\\

A Distributed Development of Word Recognition and Naming.\\

{\it Psy.Rev.} {\bf 96}(1989)523-68.



Logical Form, Origins of.(1998)\\




An Interactive Activation Model of Language Production.\\

Ch.{\bf 5} in A.W.Ellis(ed.)Vol.{\bf 1} (1985) Psychology of Language.\\



Tabor, Witney; Juiano, Cornell \& Tanenhaus, Michael K.$~~~\S5.1$\\

Parsing in a Dynamical System:

An Attractor-based Account of the Interaction of Lexical

and Structural Constraints in Sentence Processing.\\

{\it Lang.\& Cog.Processes} {\bf 12}(1997)211-271.


Tanenhaus, Michael; Spivey-Knowlton, Michael J.;

Eberhard, Kathlenn \& Sedivy, Julie C.$~~~\S4.2$\\

Integration of Visual and Linguistic Information

in Spoken Language Comprehesion.

{\it Science} {\bf 268}(1995)1632-1634.


Trueswell, John,C. ;Tanenhaus Michael K.\& Garnsey, Susan M.$~~~\S5.1$\\

Semantic Influences on Parsing:

Use of Thematic Role Information in Syntatic Ambiguity Resolution.\\

{\it J.Mem.\& Lang.} {\bf 33}(1994)285-318.


Valian, Virginia$~~~\S1.2$\\

Null Subjects:

A problem for Parameter-setting Models\\ of Linguistic Acquisition.

{\it Cognition} {\bf 35}(1990)105-122.


Repository Staff Only: item control page