What's Wrong and Right About Searle's Chinese Room Argument?

Harnad, Stevan (2001) What's Wrong and Right About Searle's Chinese Room Argument? [Book Chapter]

This is the latest version of this eprint.

Full text available as:



Searle's Chinese Room Argument showed a fatal flaw in computationalism (the idea that mental states are just computational states) and helped usher in the era of situated robotics and symbol grounding (although Searle himself thought neuroscience was the only correct way to understand the mind).

Item Type:Book Chapter
Keywords:Searle, Chinese Room Argument, Turing Test, Symbol Grounding, computationalism, cognitivism, robotics, language functionalism, neuroscience
Subjects:Psychology > Cognitive Psychology
Philosophy > Philosophy of Mind
Computer Science > Artificial Intelligence
Computer Science > Robotics
ID Code:4023
Deposited By:Harnad, Stevan
Deposited On:06 Jan 2005
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:55

Available Versions of this Item

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.

Cangelosi, A. & Harnad, S. (2000) 'The Adaptive Advantage of Symbolic

Theft Over Sensorimotor Toil: Grounding Language in Perceptual

Categories', Evolution of Communication (Special Issue on Grounding).

Churchland, P.M. & Churchland, P.S. (1990) 'Could a Machine Think?',

Scientific American, vol.262, pp.32-37.

Dietrich, E. (1990) 'Computationalism', Social Epistemology, vol.4,


Fodor, J.A. (1975) The Language of Thought, (New York: Thomas Y.Crowell).

Fodor, J.A. & Pylyshyn, Z.W. (1988) 'Connectionism and Cognitive

Architecture: A Critical Appraisal', Cognition, vol.28, pp.3-71.

Cangelosi A., Greco A. & Harnad S. (2000) 'From Robotic Toil

to Symbolic Theft: Grounding Transfer from Entry-level to

Higher-level Categories', Connection Science, vol.12, pp.143-162.

Harnad, S. (1982a) 'Neoconstructivism: A Unifying Theme for the

Cognitive Sciences', in T.Simon & R.Scholes (eds.), Language,

Mind and Brain, (Hillsdale NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum), pp.1-11.

Harnad, S. (1982b) 'Consciousness: An Afterthought',

Cognition and Brain Theory, vol.5, pp.29-47.

Harnad, S. (ed.) (1987) Categorical Perception: The Groundwork

of Cognition, (New York: Cambridge University Press).

Harnad, S. (1989) 'Minds, Machines and Searle', Journal of

Theoretical and Experimental Artificial Intelligence, vol.1, pp.5-25.

Harnad, S. (1990a) 'The Symbol Grounding

Problem', Physica D, vol.42, pp.335-346.

Harnad, S. (1990b) 'Against Computational

Hermeneutics', (Invited commentary on Eric Dietrich's

'Computationalism'), Social Epistemology, vol.4, pp.167-172.

Harnad, S. (1990c) 'Lost in the Hermeneutic Hall of

Mirrors', (Invited Commentary on: Michael Dyer, 'Minds,

Machines, Searle and Harnad'), Journal of Experimental and

Theoretical Artificial Intelligence, vol.2, pp.321-327.

Harnad, S. (1990d) 'Scholarly Skywriting and the Prepublication

Continuum of Scientific Inquiry', Psychological Science, vol.1, pp.342-3

(reprinted in Current Contents, vol.45, November 11th, 1991, pp.9-13).

Harnad, S. (1991a) 'Other Bodies, Other Minds: A Machine Incarnation

of an Old Philosophical Problem', Minds and Machines, vol.1, pp.43-54.

Harnad, S. (1991b) 'Post-Gutenberg Galaxy: The Fourth

Revolution in the Means of Production of Knowledge',

Public-Access Computer Systems Review, vol.2, pp.39-53.

Harnad, S. (1992) 'The Turing Test Is Not A Trick:

Turing Indistinguishability Is A Scientific

Criterion', SIGART Bulletin, vol.3, pp.9-10.

Harnad, S. (1993) 'Artificial Life: Synthetic Versus

Virtual', in Artificial Life III: Proceedings, Santa Fe

Institute Studies in the Sciences of Complexity. Volume XVI.

Harnad, S. (1994a) 'Levels of Functional Equivalence in Reverse

Bioengineering: The Darwinian Turing Test for Artificial Life',

Artificial Life, vol.1, pp.293-301 (reprinted in: C.G.Langton (ed.),

Artificial Life: An Overview, (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1995).

Harnad, S. (1994b) 'Computation Is Just Interpretable Symbol

Manipulation: Cognition Isn't', Minds and Machines, vol.4, pp.379-390.

Harnad, S. (1995b) 'Why and How We Are Not Zombies',

Journal of Consciousness Studies, vol.1, pp.164-167.

Harnad, S. (1996) 'The Origin of Words: A Psychophysical Hypothesis',

in B.Velichkovsky & D.Rumbaugh (eds.), Communicating Meaning: Evolution

and Development of Language, (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum), pp.27-44.

Harnad, S. (2000a) 'Machines, and Turing: The Indistinguishability of

Indistinguishables', Journal of Logic, Language, and Information, vol.9,

(special issue on "Alan Turing and Artificial Intelligence"), pp.425-45.

Harnad, S. (2000b) 'Correlation Vs. Causality: How/Why the Mind/Body

Problem Is Hard' [Invited Commentary on Nick Humphrey's, 'How to Solve the

Mind-Body Problem'], Journal of Consciousness Studies, vol.7, pp.54-61.

Harnad, S. (2001) 'Explaining the Mind: Problems, Problems',

The Sciences, (New York Academy of Sciences), April.

Harnad, S. Hanson, S.J. & Lubin, J. (1995) 'Learned Categorical

Perception in Neural Nets: Implications for Symbol Grounding', in:

V.Honavar & L.Uhr (eds.), Symbol Processors and Connectionist Network

Models in Artificial Intelligence and Cognitive Modelling: Steps Toward

Principled Integration, New York & London: Academic Press, pp. 191-206.

Harnad, S., Steklis, H.D. & Lancaster, J.B. (eds.), (1976) Origins and

Evolution of Language and Speech, Annals of the New York Academy of

Sciences, vol.280.

Hayes, P., Harnad, S., Perlis, D. & Block, N. (1992) 'Virtual Symposium

on Virtual Mind', Minds and Machines, vol.2, pp.217-238.

Heyes, C.M. (1998) 'Theory of Mind in Nonhuman Primates',

Behavioral and Brain Sciences, vol.21, pp.101-134.

Hexter, J.H. (1979) Reappraisals in History, (Chicago: University of

Chicago Press).

Lucas, J.R. (1961) 'Minds, Machines and Gödel', Philosophy, vol.36,


Lucas, M.M. & Hayes, P.J. (eds.), (1982) Proceedings of the Cognitive

Curriculum Conference. University of Rochester.

Newell, A. (1980) 'Physical Symbol Systems', Cognitive Science, vol.4,


Luria, A.R. (1972) The Man with a Shattered World, (New York: Basic


Premack, D. & Woodruff, G. 1978. 'Does the Chimpanzee Have a Theory of

Mind?', Behavioral & Brain Sciences, vol.1, pp.515-526.

Pylyshyn, Z.W. (1980) 'Computation and Cognition: Issues in the

Foundations of Cognitive Science', Behavioral and Brain Sciences, vol.3,


Pylyshyn, Z.W. (1984) Computation and Cognition: Toward a Foundation

for Cognitive Science, (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).

Pylyshyn, Z.W. (ed.), (1987) The Robot's Dilemma: The Frame Problem in

Artificial Intelligence, (Norwood, NJ: Ablex).

Searle, J.R. (1980a) 'Minds, Brains, and Programs',

Behavioral and Brain Sciences, vol.3, pp.417-57.

Searle, J.R. (1980b) 'Intrinsic Intentionality', Behavioral and Brain

Sciences, vol.3, pp.450-6.

Searle, J.R. (1982) 'The Chinese Room Revisited', Behavioral and Brain

Sciences, vol.5, pp.345-8.

Searle, J.R. (1984) Minds, Brains, and Science, (Cambridge, MA: Harvard

University Press).

Searle, J.R. (1987) 'Minds and Brains Without Programs', in C.Blakemore &

S.Greenfield (eds), Mindwaves, Oxford: Basil Blackwell, pp.208-33.

Searle, J.R. (1990a) 'Consciousness, Explanatory Inversion and Cognitive

Science', Behavioral and Brain Sciences, vol.13, pp.585-96.

Searle, J.R. (1990b) 'Is the Brain's Mind a Computer Program?', Scientific

American, vol.262, pp.20-5.

Steklis, H.D. & Harnad, S. (1976) 'From Hand to Mouth: Some Critical

Stages in the Evolution of Language', in Harnad et al. (eds.), 1976,


Turing, A.M. (1950) 'Computing Machinery and Intelligence', Mind,

vol.49, pp.433-460.

Wittgenstein, L. (1953) Philosophical Investigations, (New York:



Repository Staff Only: item control page