LANGUAGE AS A MIRROR OF THE WORLD: Reconciling picture theory and language games

Allott, Robin (2003) LANGUAGE AS A MIRROR OF THE WORLD: Reconciling picture theory and language games. [Preprint]

Full text available as:



Wittgenstein in the Tractatus focussed on a picture theory of language. He was clear that this meant that language mirrored reality, mirrored the world. The picture theory was an account in essence of the relation between a word and what it referred to in the external environment, or between a sentence, a proposition or sachverhalt and the event or situation to which it referred. The Tractatus was completed in 1919 and published in 1922. Within the space of 11 years after its publication Wittgenstein had abandoned the picture theory and, in the Blue Book and the Brown Book, sketched out a quite different account of language as a congeries of language games, and different languages as different sets of language games; words were given their meanings by use, by explanation, by training and essentially by social interaction. This changed account took its definitive form in the Philosophical Investigations, posthumously published in 1953. Wittgenstein did not wholly abandon the Tractatus and would have liked the Tractatus and his later writings to be published together, though this was never done before his early death (Hacker 1996). There is a problem how he could have presented two such different accounts of language with equal conviction. Can they be reconciled? The examination in much greater depth of both may solve the problem. Since the Tractatus and the Philosophical Investigations, there have been massive advances in different but equally relevant fields: in linguistics, in neurology, in philosophical discussion, in evolutionary theory, in psychology, in child development. Most recently and relevantly, there has been the discovery of mirror neurons (Rizzolatti & Arbib 1998), neurons which are excited by the perception of action and which seem to constitute the precursors of motor programs to reproduce the perceived action, that is, a plausible basis for imitation and communication. There has also been great progress in the study of the active brain in the production of speech, using fMRI, PET, ERP, MEG and there are new ideas on the motor basis of speech production and speech perception, on the relation of speech and gesture, on visual and auditory perception. The paper will suggest that in the light of all these developments Wittgenstein's two accounts of language can be reconciled within a larger framework, and the philosophy and science of language can profitably be linked with each other.

Item Type:Preprint
Additional Information:presented at 30th LACUS, Victoria University, Canada
Keywords:Wittgenstein, mirror neurons, Rorty, motor control, Chomsky, minimalism, language evolution, brain-scanning
Subjects:Philosophy > Philosophy of Language
ID Code:3110
Deposited By:Allott, R M
Deposited On:16 Aug 2003
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:55

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.

Allott, R. 1992. The Motor Theory of Language: Origin and Function. In Language Origin: A Multidisciplinary Approach ed. by Jan Wind et al. NATO ASI. Dordrecht: Kluwer

Anscombe, G.E.M. 1995. "Ludwig Wittgenstein". Philosophy 70: 273 395. Arbib, M. A., E.J. Conklin and J. Hill. 1987. From Schema Theory to Language. OUP.

Ayer A.J. 1985 Ludwig Wittgenstein. Penguin.

Bartley, W.W. 1985 Wittgenstein. Open Court.

Berthoz, Alain. 1997. Le Sens du Mouvement. Editions Odile Jacob.

Bilgrami, A. 2002. "Chomsky and Philosophy". Mind & Language 17: 3 290-302..

Bloomfield, L. 1933. [Reprint 1970]. Language. Allen and Unwin.

Chomsky, N. 1988. Language and Problems of Knowledge: The Managua Lectures. MIT.

Chomsky, N. 1993. Language and Thought. Moyer Bell. .

Chomsky, N. 1993. "A minimalist program for linguistic theory" in K Hale and J Keyser eds. The View from Building 20. MIT.

Chomsky, N. 1995. The Minimalist Program. MIT.

Chomsky, N. 2000. New Horizons in the Study of Language and Mind. CUP.

Deacon, T.W. 1997. The Symbolic Species: The Co-evolution of Language and the Brain. Norton.

Decety, J. 1996. "Do imagined and executed actions share the same neural substrate?" Cog. Brain Res. 3: 87-93 .

Decety, J. ed. 2000. "Cerveau, Perception et Action". Psychologie Française. 45 4.

Fadiga, L., G. Craighero, G. Buccino and G. Rizzolatti. 2002. "Speech listening specifically modulates the excitability of tongue muscles: a TMS study". European Journal of Neuroscience 15 : 399-402.

Fromkin, V. A. 1997." Some Thoughts about the Brain/Mind/Language Interface". Lingua 100. 3-27

Gallese, V. 1998." Mirror neurons: from grasping to language". In Towards a |Science of Consciousness (Tucson III)

Graziano Michael SA, Taylor Charlotte SR, Moore Trin. 2002. "Complex movements evoked by microstimulation of precentral cortex". Neuron 34, 841-851.

Hacker, P.M.S. 1996. Wittgenstein's Place in Twentieth-century Analytic Philosophy. Blackwell.

Hale, K. and S.J. Keyser. 1993. The View from Building 20. MIT.

Harnad, S.R., Steklis, H.D., and J. Lancaster. 1976. Origins and Evolution of Language and Speech. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. Vol. 280.

Hornstein, N. 1995. Logical Form: From GB to Minimalism. Blackwell .

Hurford, J. R. 2002. "Language beyond our grasp: what mirror neurons can, and cannot, do for language evolution". In The Evolution of Communication Systems: A Comparative Approach. ed. by D. Kimbrough Oller, U. Griebel and K. Plunkett. MIT.

Iacoboni, M., R.P. Woods, M. Brass, H. Bekkering, J.C. Mazziotta and G. Rizzolatti. 1999. "Cortical Mechanisms of Human Imitation". Science 286 2526-2528.

Jackendoff, R. 2002. Foundations of language :brain, meaning, grammar, evolution. OUP.

Kenny, Anthony. "The Ghost of the Tractatus". In Vesey ed. 1-13.

Kohler, E., C., Keysers, M.A., Umilta, L., Fogassi, V., Gallese and G. Rizzolatti. 2002. "Hearing Sounds Understanding Actions: Action Representation in Mirror Neurons". Science 297 846-8.

Liberman, A.M. et al. 1967. "Perception of the speech code". Psychological Review74: 431-461.

Liberman, A. M. and I. G. Mattingly. 1985. "The motor theory of speech perception revised." Cognition 21: 1-36.

Lyons, J. 1968. Introduction to Theoretical Linguistics. CUP.

Malcolm, N. 1958. Ludwig Wittgenstein: A Memoir (with a Biographical Sketch by G. H. von Wright). OUP.

Monk, R. 1990. Ludwig Wittgenstein: The Duty of Genius. Jonathan Cape.

Moravcsik, J.M. 2002. "Chomsky's New Horizons". Mind & Language 17: 3 303-311.

Mussa-Ivaldi, F.A., Giszter, S.F., Bizzi, E. 1994. "Linear combinations of primitives in vertebrate motor control." Proc Natl Acad Sci 2;91(16):7534-8

O'Grady, P. 1996 "Anscombe on the Tractatus". Philosophy 71: 276.

Pulvermüller F 1999. "Words in the Brain's Language". Brain and Behavioral Sciences. 22, 2, 253-279

Pulvermüller F., Lutzenberger, W., Preissl, H. 1999. "Nouns and verbs in the intact brain: evidence from event-related potentials and high-frequency cortical responses." Cereb Cortex 9(5):497-506.

Pulvermüller, F., Mohr, B., Schleichert, H. 1999. "Semantic or lexico-syntactic factors: what determines word-class specific activity in the human brain?" Neurosci Lett 12;275(2):81-4

Raichle, M. E. 1994. "Visualizing the Mind: Strategies of cognitive science and techniques of modern brain imaging open a window to the neural systems responsible for thought". Scientific American 270(4): 36-42.

Rijntjes, M., Dettmers, C., Buchei, C., Kiebel, S., Frackoviak, J., Weiller, C. 1999. "A blueprint for movement: Functional and anatomical representations in the human motor system." J. Neurosci 19(18):8043-8048.

Rizzolatti, G. and M.A. Arbib. 1998. "Language within our grasp". Trends in Neurosciences. 21(5) 188-194.

Rorty, R. 1979, Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature. Princeton UP.

Rowe, M.W. 1992. "The Definition of 'Game'. Philosophy 67: 262 467.

Russell, B. 1959. My Philosophical Development. Allen & Unwin.

Saussure, F. 1915. Course in General Linguistics. Trans. W. Baskin. McGraw-Hill 1966.

Stone, T. and M. Davies. 2002. "Chomsky among the Philosophers". Mind & Language 17 3 276-289.

Vesey, G. ed. 1974. Understanding Wittgenstein. Cornell.

Vesey, G. 1974. Foreword In Vesey ed.

von Wright, G.H. "Biographical Sketch". In Malcolm Ludwig Wittgenstein. 1-22.

White, R.M. "Can whether one proposition makes sense depend on the truth of another? In Vesey ed. 14-29.

Wittgenstein, L. 1922. Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus. Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Wittgenstein L. 1953. Philosophical Investigations. Translated by G.E.M. Anscombe. Blackwell.

Wittgenstein, L. 1960. The Blue and Brown Books. Blackwell.

Wittgenstein, L. 1961. Notebooks 1914-1916. Blackwell.

Wittgenstein, L. 1967. Zettel. Blackwell.


Repository Staff Only: item control page