Acta Cum Fundamentis in Re

Smith, B. (1984) Acta Cum Fundamentis in Re. [Journal (Paginated)]

Full text available as:

[img] HTML


It will be the thesis of this paper that there are among our mental acts some which fall into the category of real material relations. That is: some acts are necessarily such as to involve a plurality of objects as their relata or fundamenta. Suppose Bruno walks into his study and sees a cat. To describe the seeing, here, as a relation, is to affirm that it serves somehow to tie Bruno to the cat. Bruno's act of seeing, unlike his feeling depressed, his putative thinking-about-Santa-Claus or his musing, abstractedly, about the tallest spy, has at least two fundamenta: it is, as a matter of necessity, dependent for its existence upon both Bruno himself and the cat that he sees. This idea will naturally raise echoes of Russell's doctrine of knowledge by acquaintance. 'I am acquainted with an object', Russell tells us, 'when I have a direct cognitive relation to that object, i. e. when I am directly aware of the object itself' (1918, p. 209). And indeed a distinction in many ways like that between acquaintance and description will find a place within the theory here projected, but there are crucial differences.

Item Type:Journal (Paginated)
Subjects:Philosophy > Metaphysics
ID Code:305
Deposited By: Smith, Barry
Deposited On:09 Jun 1998
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:53


Repository Staff Only: item control page