There Is Only One Mind/Body Problem

Harnad, Stevan (1992) There Is Only One Mind/Body Problem. [Conference Paper] (Unpublished)

Full text available as:



In our century a Frege/Brentano wedge has gradually been driven into the mind/body problem so deeply that it appears to have split it into two: The problem of "qualia" and the problem of "intentionality." Both problems use similar intuition pumps: For qualia, we imagine a robot that is indistinguishable from us in every objective respect, but it lacks subjective experiences; it is mindless. For intentionality, we again imagine a robot that is indistinguishable from us in every objective respect but its "thoughts" lack "aboutness"; they are meaningless. I will try to show that there is a way to re-unify the mind/body problem by grounding the "language of thought" (symbols) in our perceptual categorization capacity. The model is bottom-up and hybrid symbolic/nonsymbolic.

Item Type:Conference Paper
Keywords:mind/body problem, qualia, intentionality, Turing test, Total Turing Test
Subjects:Psychology > Cognitive Psychology
Philosophy > Philosophy of Mind
ID Code:1625
Deposited By:Harnad, Stevan
Deposited On:19 Jun 2001
Last Modified:11 Mar 2011 08:54

References in Article

Select the SEEK icon to attempt to find the referenced article. If it does not appear to be in cogprints you will be forwarded to the paracite service. Poorly formated references will probably not work.

Harnad, S., Steklis, H. D. & Lancaster, J. B. (eds.) (1976) Origins and Evolution of Language and

Speech. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 280.

Harnad, S. (1982) Neoconstructivism: A unifying theme for the cognitive sciences. In: Language, mind

and brain (T. Simon & R. Scholes, eds., Hillsdale NJ: Erlbaum), 1 - 11.

Harnad, S. (1982) Consciousness: An afterthought. Cognition and Brain Theory 5: 29 - 47.

Harnad, S. (1984) Verifying machines' minds. (Review of J. T. Culbertson, Consciousness: Natural

and artificial, NY: Libra 1982.) Contemporary Psychology 29: 389 - 391.

Harnad, S. (1984) What are the scope and limits of radical behaviorist theory? Behavioral and Brain

Sciences 7: 720 -721.

Harnad, S. (ed.) (1987) Categorical Perception: The Groundwork of Cognition. New York: Cambridge

University Press.

Harnad, S. (1987) The induction and representation of categories. In: Harnad 1987. harnad87.categorization.html

Harnad, S. (1989) Minds, Machines and Searle. Journal of Theoretical and Experimental Artificial

Intelligence 1: 5-25.

Harnad, S. (1990) The Symbol Grounding Problem. Physica D 42: 335-346.

Harnad, S. (1990) Against Computational Hermeneutics. (Invited commentary on Eric Dietrich's

Computationalism) Social Epistemology 4: 167-172.

Harnad, S. (1990) Lost in the hermeneutic hall of mirrors. Invited Commentary on: Michael Dyer:

Minds, Machines, Searle and Harnad. Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Artificial Intelligence 2:

321 - 327.

Harnad, S. (1990) Symbols and Nets: Cooperation vs. Competition. Review of: S. Pinker and J.

Mehler (Eds.) (1988) Connections and Symbols Connection Science 2: 257-260.

Harnad, S. (1991) Other bodies, Other minds: A machine incarnation of an old philosophical problem.

Minds and Machines 1: 43-54.

Harnad, S., Hanson, S.J. & Lubin, J. (1991) Categorical Perception and the Evolution of Supervised

Learning in Neural Nets. Presented at Symposium on Symbol Grounding: Problems and Practice,

Stanford University, March 1991 In: Proceedings of the AAAI Spring Symposium on Machine

Learning of Natural Language and Ontology (DW Powers & L Reeker, Eds.) Document D91-09,

Deutsches Forschungszentrum fur Kuenstliche Intelligenz GmbH Kaiserslautern FRG, pp. 65-74.

Harnad, S. (1992) Connecting Object to Symbol in Modeling Cognition. In: A. Clark and R. Lutz (Eds)

Connectionism in Context Springer Verlag, pp 75 - 90.

Harnad, S. (1992) The Turing Test Is Not A Trick: Turing Indistinguishability Is A Scientific Criterion.

SIGART Bulletin 3(4) (October) 9 - 10.

Hayes, P., Harnad, S., Perlis, D. & Block, N. (1992) Virtual Symposium on Virtual Mind. Minds and

Machines 2: 217-238.

Harnad, S. (1993) Grounding Symbols in the Analog World with Neural Nets. Think 2(1) 12 - 78

(Special issue on "Connectionism versus Symbolism," D.M.W. Powers & P.A. Flach, eds.). [Also

reprinted in French translation as: "L'Ancrage des Symboles dans le Monde Analogique a l'aide de

Reseaux Neuronaux: un Modele Hybride." In: Rialle V. et Payette D. (Eds) La Modelisation.

LEKTON, Vol IV, No 2.]

Harnad, S. (1993) Artificial Life: Synthetic Versus Virtual. Artificial Life III. Proceedings, Santa Fe

Institute Studies in the Sciences of Complexity. Volume XVI.

Harnad, S. (1993) Symbol Grounding is an Empirical Problem: Neural Nets are Just a Candidate

Component. Proceedings of the Fifteenth Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society. NJ:


Harnad, S. (1993) Problems, Problems: The Frame Problem as a Symptom of the Symbol Grounding

Problem. PSYCOLOQUY 4(34) frame-problem.11

Harnad, S. (1993) Exorcizing the Ghost of Mental Imagery. Commentary on: JI Glasgow: "The

Imagery Debate Revisited." Computational Intelligence 9(4) 309-333.

Harnad S. (1993) Discussion (passim) In: Bock, G.R. & Marsh, J. (Eds.) Experimental and Theoretical

Studies of Consciousness. CIBA Foundation Symposium 174. Chichester: Wiley

Harnad, S. (1994) Levels of Functional Equivalence in Reverse Bioengineering: The Darwinian Turing

Test for Artificial Life. Artificial Life 1(3): 293-301. Reprinted in: C.G. Langton (Ed.). Artifial Life: An

Overview. MIT Press 1995.

Harnad S, (1994) The Convergence Argument in Mind-Modelling: Scaling Up from Toyland to the

Total Turing Test. Cognoscenti 1:

Harnad, S. (1994) Computation Is Just Interpretable Symbol Manipulation: Cognition Isn't. Special

Issue on "What Is Computation" Minds and Machines 4:379-390 [Also appears in French translation in

"Penser l'Esprit: Des Sciences de la Cognition a une Philosophie Cognitive," V. Rialle & D. Fisette,

Eds. Presses Universite de Grenoble. 1996]

Harnad, S, (1995) Does the Mind Piggy-Back on Robotic and Symbolic Capacity? In: H. Morowitz

(ed.) "The Mind, the Brain, and Complex Adaptive Systems." Santa Fe Institute Studies in the

Sciences of Complexity. Volume XXII. P. 204-220.

Harnad, S. (1995) Grounding Symbolic Capacity in Robotic Capacity. In: Steels, L. and R. Brooks

(eds.) The Artificial Life Route to Artificial Intelligence: Building Embodied Situated Agents. New

Haven: Lawrence Erlbaum. Pp. 277-286.

Harnad, S. Hanson, S.J. & Lubin, J. (1995) Learned Categorical Perception in Neural Nets:

Implications for Symbol Grounding. In: V. Honavar & L. Uhr (eds) Symbol Processors and

Connectionist Network Models in Artificial Intelligence and Cognitive Modelling: Steps Toward

Principled Integration. Academic Press. pp. 191-206.

Harnad, S. (1995) Why and How We Are Not Zombies. Journal of Consciousness Studies 1: 164-167.

Harnad, S. (1995) The Warp Factor. Guardian (OnLine: OffLine) Thursday February 23 1995. P. 11.

Harnad, S. (1995) Grounding symbols in sensorimotor categories with neural networks. In: IEE

Colloquium "Grounding Representations: Integration of Sensory Information in Natural Language

Processing, Artificial Intelligence and Neural Networks" (Digest No.1995/103).

Harnad, S. (1995) What Thoughts Are Made Of. Nature 378: 455-456. Book Review of: Churchland,

PM. (1995) The Engine of Reason, the Seat of the Soul: A Philosophical Journey into the Brain (MIT

Press) and Greenfield, SA (1995) Journey to the Centers of the Mind. (Freeman) Nature (1995)

Harnad, S. (1996) The Origin of Words: A Psychophysical Hypothesis In Velichkovsky B &

Rumbaugh, D. (Eds.) "Communicating Meaning: Evolution and Development of Language. NJ:

Erlbaum: pp 27-44.

Harnad, S. (1996) Experimental Analysis of Naming Behavior Cannot Explain Naming Capacity.

Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior 65: 262-264.

Harnad, S. (1996) What to Do About Feelings? [Published as "Conscious Ecumenism" Review of

PSYCHE: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Research on Consciousness] Times Higher Education

Supplement. June 7 1996, P. 29.

Cangelosi, A., Greco, A. & Harnad, S. (1996) Categorical perception effects in connectionist models.

Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the Italian Psychological Association. Experimental

Psychology Section. Capri, 30 September 1996.

Greco, A., Cangelosi, A. & Harnad, S. (1997) A connectionist model of categorical perception and

symbol grounding. Proceedings of the 15th Annual Workshop of the European Society for the Study of

Cognitive Systems. Freiburg (D). January 1997: 7.

Harnad, S. (1997) "Lively Flights of Fancy." Book review of M. Boden (ed.) "The Philosophy of

Artificial Life." Blackwell. Times Higher Education Supplement. January 31, 1997

Pevtzow, R. & Harnad, S. (1997) Warping Similarity Space in Category Learning by Human Subjects:

The Role of Task Difficulty. In: Ramscar, M., Hahn, U., Cambouropolos, E. & Pain, H. (Eds.)

Proceedings of SimCat 1997: Interdisciplinary Workshop on Similarity and Categorization. Department

of Artificial Intelligence, Edinburgh University: 189 - 195.

Tijsseling, A. & Harnad, S. (1997) Warping Similarity Space in Category Learning by Backprop Nets.

In: Ramscar, M., Hahn, U., Cambouropolos, E. & Pain, H. (Eds.) Proceedings of SimCat 1997:

Interdisciplinary Workshop on Similarity and Categorization. Department of Artificial Intelligence,

Edinburgh University: 263 - 269.

Andrews, J., Livingston, K. & Harnad, S. (1998). Categorical Perception Effects Induced by Category

Learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition.

Harnad, S. (1998) Turing Indistinguishability and the Blind Watchmaker. In: Mulhauser, G. (ed.)

"Evolving Consciousness" Amsterdam: John Benjamins (in press)

Harnad, S. (1998) Beyond Object Constancy. Institution of Electrical Engineers (IEE) Seminar on

"Self-Learning Robots II: Bio-Robotics" (Digest 98/248: 2/1-2/3)

Greco, A., Cangelosi, A., & Harnad, S. (1998) A Connectionist Model for Categorical Perception and

Symbol Grounding.

Harnad, S. (1998) Hardships of Cognitive Science. Review of J. Shear (Ed.) Explaining Consciousness

(MIT/Bradford 1997) Trends in Cognitive Sciences (in press)

Csato, L., Kovacs, G, Harnad, S. Pevtzow, R & Lorincz, A. (submitted) Category Learning,

Categorisation Difficulty and Categorical Perception: Compututational Modules and behavioural

Evidence. Connection Science.

Greco, A., Cangelosi, A., & Harnad, S. (in prep.) A Connectionist Model for Categorical Perception

and Symbol Grounding.

Cangelosi, A & Harnad, S. (in prep) On the Virtues of Theft Over Honest Toil: Grounding Language

and Thought in Sensorimotor Categories: Grounding Language and thought in Senosimotor Categories.

Harnad, S. (in prep) From Praxis to Pantomime to Propositions: Communicative Continuum or

Cognitive Hurdles? (Proceedings of the Language Origins Society)

Harnad, S. (in preparation) Icon, Category, Symbol: Essays on the Foundations and Fringes of

Cognition. Cambridge University Press.


Repository Staff Only: item control page